The Other Vietnam

Speaking at the UN Human    Rights Council on June 27, on behalf of the Vietnam Committee on Human Rights (VCHR) and its partner Agir Ensemble pour les Droits de l'Homme, VCHR President Vo Van Ai denounced the violent suppression of peaceful demonstrations and the adoption of a restrictive new Cybersecurity Law in Vietnam.

"Vietnam's one-Party state, where there are no opposition parties and no free press, peaceful demonstrations and the Internet are the only means people have to freely express their views".

Since 9th June massive protests have shaken the country, notably in Ho Chi Minh City, Hanoi, Nha Tiang and Binh Thuan province. Thousands, of people have taken to the streets to denounce a draft law that would allow foreign investors to lease land for periods of 99 years in three Special Economic Zones (SEZs). For many Vietnamese, this law would give China a golden opportunity to establish a long-term presence in Vietnam at a time when the Chinese authorities are taking a particularly aggressive stand on Sino Vietnamese territorial disputes in the South China seas (called the Eastern Sea by the Vietnamese).

Vietnam reacted to these demonstrations with a massive and brutal crack-down. Police and plain-clothed security agents beat and arrested both protesters and passers-by, and deployed Long Range Acoustic Devices (LRADs) to forcibly disband the protests. Temporary detention certres were set up (such as Tao Dan Park in Ho Chi Minh City) where Police conducted interrogations. Those released report that they "could hear screams of other activists being beaten by Police" in adjacent rooms. Some 300 people remain in detention and dozens now face criminal charges for alleged "breaches of public order".

"These nationwide protests are not just about Chinese encroachment". "Many demonstrators were also denouncing the new cybersecurity law. This unrest is a sign of the people's need to speak out freely, and their deep frustration to be living in a society where their only right is to keep silent".

In his statement to the UN, Mr Ai declared that the cybersecurity law "deals a severe blow to freedom of expression online. It grants the government sweeping powers to monitor online activity and requires social media platforms to store the personal data of its users in Vietnam and remove content deemed 'offensive' by the government within 24 hours".

The law, which was adopted by the National Assembly on 12th June and comes into force in January 2019, also prohibits Internet users from using social networks or the Internet to "infringe upon state interests" or spread "false information". These vague, catch-all charges are routinely invoked by the government to muzzle all freedom of expression.

In fact, the new Cybersecurity law not only concerns users of social media but all individuals and companies who access the Internet. For example, companies offering online services could be obliged to share the personal data of their clients, including bank accounts, hotel booking, travel itineraries or online purchases with the authorities if they are so requested.

"Potentially, this law gives the authorities carte-blanche to censor, monitor, spy and crack down anyone in their sights, whether they be Vietnamese or foreigners in Vietnam".

Mr Ai called upon the UN Human Rights Council to firmly condemn the Vietnamese government, and press Vietnam to "immediately release all those arrested in the demonstrations, and prosecute Police and security agents responsible for excessive use of force, arbitrary detention, or ill-treatment in custody".

Vietnam, the face of resistance against imperialist barbarism, now presents a completely different picture. It's now the face of totalitarianism, silencing any voice of dissent with iron hands.


Vol. 51, No.2, Jul 15 - 21, 2018